Far too often I’ve seen people post screenshots of what are supposedly news articles with the name of the source cropped out, or someone will claim that a news event happened without citing an actual source. When I call them out on this they often respond with “Just google it”.
This isn’t the early 2000s anymore, and yet people are still saying variations of the phrase “Do your own research”. So I’m going to explain why you should always cite a source when talking about the news, and why telling people to “just google it” doesn’t work.
First the algorithm that Google uses, like the algorithm that all other major sites use, gives different results to different people. That’s why people disagree so much about the facts. When someone claims that shapeshifting reptiles control the world, they’re using the same thought process to come to that conclusion that most people use. It’s just that they’ve been given different “evidence” by the algorithms. This is how echo chambers work.
Conspiracy theorists aren’t any dumber than most other people, they’ve just been hit with results that other people haven’t been hit with. So it really doesn’t make sense to tell someone to “just google it” and expect them to form the same result you did.
Secondly the people who post these stories on social media often make them up entirely. It can take time to debunk a claim, but it takes no amount of time to come up with a story, especially when most people have a flimsy understanding of what kind of stories seem realistic.
This is a huge problem with community notes. It offloads the thinking to selected people, and it normalizes the idea that you should just believe any story you come across on social media so long as it doesn’t have a community note.
It’s not the skeptic’s job to debunk stupid claims. It’s the job of those making the claim to back it up with something. In the time it takes to debunk one claim ten more can take it’s place.
The burden of proof lies on the one making the claim. It’s not my job to test your claim for you. Anyone who’s serious about resisting propaganda should disregard any news stories that don’t, at the very least, have a link to the news story.
People should know better by now than to just believe everything they see on the Internet. It’s especially frustrating when there isn’t even so much as a screenshot of the supposed news article, or when the screenshot cropped the name of the source out.
People will literally believe something they read just because they think it sounds true. So they come to the conclusion that the world is secretly ruled by shapeshifting reptiles, they’ll come across a claim that someone on the news had their reptilian cloak malfunction, there won’t even be so much as an image attached to the post, and then people will mentally add that to their list of “facts” that supposedly prove that reptilians exist.
It’s not just conspiracy theorists, of course. People are convinced that America is some kind of rape culture, because they keep seeing people posting stories about people having been raped. Many have even gone so far as to claim that we should just automatically believe any woman who claims to have been raped regardless of if there’s evidence.
They claim that false reports are rare (without ever citing a source) and they expect us to literally just automatically believe these claims made by complete strangers.
One would think that it’s obvious that we shouldn’t just blindly believe every claim we come across on the Internet, yet I’ve seen people in arguments bring up a story about something that supposedly happened as evidence of what they’re saying, and then the other side will seemingly just assume that it’s true and try to come up with explanations for why the story happened that makes it seem like it’s not very good evidence.
“Just googling it” doesn’t work, not just because the search engine is giving different people different results, but also because these stories often don’t provide the details needed to even search for them. I cannot stress to you enough why “just google it” is intellectual laziness.
The people posting this propaganda know damn well that most people won’t “just google it” anyways, so I take it upon myself to call into question these claims so other people can see my posts and realize that they shouldn’t just blindly believe propaganda.
People say “trust the experts” and yet they don’t seem to understand how experts operate. Citing sources is not optional.
As Carl Sagan put it “Extraordinary claims call for extraordinary evidence.” He didn’t say “Extraordinary claims call for you to just look it up to verify that it’s true.” as that would be obviously absurd.
The next time you see someone not post a source do the right thing and, at a bare minimum, don’t just believe what they’re saying.